Véronique Poujol puts her name to her investigations. She makes her name, her methodology and her accountability clear. Her articles may be challenged. Those she accuses may request a right of reply, refer the matter to the Press Council or take legal action.
Those who set up the website attacking her have chosen a different approach. They use her name as the website address, level extremely serious accusations against her and adopt the formal conventions of journalism. But they do not sign anything. They reveal neither who is writing, nor who is funding, nor who is calling the shots. They cite anonymous sources who cannot be questioned and do not produce the evidence that would allow for a proper debate.
That’s not civic courage. It’s a covert operation.
Technology has significantly reduced the cost of this despicable act. A domain name costing one cent a year, a service designed to conceal the infrastructure for a few euros more, and artificial intelligence are all that is needed to produce a fake report in a matter of hours, translate it into several languages and make it look like a well-researched piece of work. The accusation can then circulate whilst its author remains anonymous.
Democracy allows for the harshest criticism. It even protects statements that disturb, shock or cause offence. But it is also based on accountability. A public accusation requires verifiable facts. An investigation requires a method. An accuser must be able to account for what they publish.
Anonymity can protect a vulnerable source, a whistleblower or someone at risk of reprisals. It takes on a different character when it is used to methodically construct a campaign directed against an identifiable person, without anyone in charge being willing to take responsibility for its content.
This case concerns Véronique Poujol, but it serves as a warning to all journalists. Anyone who carries out investigative journalism now knows that an adversary can buy their name, fabricate a digital case against them and plant accusations in search engines without ever revealing their identity.
We at Paperjam – its management and editorial team – offer our full support to Véronique Poujol. We call on those who designed, funded or contributed to this website to come forward and present their evidence. Failing that, we call on the authorities to identify them and on technical service providers to preserve the necessary data. It is for the courts and the legislature – which defines the framework within which our societies operate – to set the boundaries of what can and cannot be done with impunity.
A democracy does not require journalists to be beyond reproach. It requires that dissent be possible. You cannot debate with a shadow. You cannot verify the sources of a ghost. And you do not defend democracy by anonymously orchestrating the destruction of those who investigate on its behalf.



